The judge won. He said his decisions were not open to question. The Sala IV of Costa Rica agreed. A judge can make whatever decision he or she wants in a case, and it is not up for discussion. The office of judicial inspections were told not to question the decisions — even in cases where there may be obvious bribery or fraud.
The Sala IV said that a judge's decision could be overturned by a superior court, but could not be voided by anyone besides him or herself. The decision would seem to reject any oversight of judicial decisions.
The Sala IV ordered the judicial inspection department of the court to reinstate a judge who made a suspicious decision and pay all his back wages because the office suspended him wrongly. The inspectors questioned one of his decisions and suspended the judge because investigators felt there was some monkey business going on concerning a civil collection case.